It's official!
I received a wonderfully fat envelope from the Journal of Urban History this afternoon. After seven long months of waiting, I finally heard back and the result is...
is...
revise and resubmit!
This is not as bad as it sounds. It was actually the best response I could have realistically hoped for. The alternative was a straight decline to review, which happens to most people, most of the time. This same paper has been declined without review at my ultimate publication destination, but this journal is a very close second. I am so pleased!
At this point, my article has already been peer reviewed and I have received extensive comments and suggestions from my two amazingly dedicated anonymous reviewers. The reviewers had a lot of suggestions, but nothing that will require an extensive re-write and nothing that I can't handle with a few months of work. Once I revise according to their suggestions, I resubmit to the journal and hope for the best. Sometimes a second revision is needed, sometimes it is taken at that point for publication, and sometimes it is declined and the process starts all over again with another journal. This can all take a very, very long time. I'll be lucky to have more than one article published before I get my degree (!).
On a previous note, more ideas for a paper for my Death and Dying class: an examination of urban roadside death memorials, an analysis of the rhetoric of cancer (is it seen as a war or as a misfortune?), or something about the life-threatening levels of urban healthcare options for the poor and working class. Or something having to do with the imagination of death, how we think of it in various forms as brought by various causes, similar in methodology to how we understand the imagination of nation and community. This would have to be much, much narrower. I don't feel any closer to a decision than I did earlier in the week. This is difficult. I haven't thought enough about death to have many ideas that sing.
Sigh.
Labels: Inspiration, School


